Administration Observatory in the Arab Region · Citizens VoicePressSearch
مرصد الإدارةin the Arab RegionCitizens Voice

Home / Annual report 2026

Public Services, Resources and Opportunities: Access and Experience

What citizens report across ten Arab states, Wave 1 (2026)
Dr Anis Ben Brik · 2026Download the report (PDF)

مرصد الإدارةin the Arab RegionCitizens Voice

Annual report 2026

Public Services, Resources and Opportunities: Access and Experience

What citizens report across ten Arab states, Wave 1 (2026)

Dr Anis Ben Brik

2026

Annual report 2026

Public Services, Resources and Opportunities: Access and Experience

What citizens report across ten Arab states, Wave 1 (2026)

Dr Anis Ben Brik

Administration Observatory in the Arab Region

Public Services, Resources and Opportunities: Access and Experience. What citizens report across ten Arab states, Wave 1 (2026).

Please cite this publication as: Ben Brik, A. (2026). Public Services, Resources and Opportunities: Access and Experience. What citizens report across ten Arab states, Wave 1 (2026). Administration Observatory in the Arab Region (Marsad Edara), https://marsad-edara.org/report/annual-2026/.

Country names and flags follow the usage of the League of Arab States. Samples are non-probability samples; scores describe respondents rather than national populations, and comparisons are indicative. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the institutions with which he is affiliated.

© Anis Ben Brik 2026. This work is made available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0). The work must be cited. Flags: flag-icons (MIT).

§toc§

Table of contents

Figures

  1. Figure 1. The state of play: access, experience and the gap
  2. Figure 2. The access–experience gap by domain
  3. Figure 3. Gap profiles by state
  4. Figure 4. Gap-type membership
  5. Figure 5. Stability of classification

Tables

  1. Table 1. Regional access, experience and gap by domain
  2. Table 2. Access, experience and the gap by state
  3. Table 3. The gap in the five interface domains
  4. Table 4. Gap-type membership and stability
  5. Table 5. Reform directions by gap type
  6. Table 6. Practitioner recommendations
  7. Table 7. Access by state and domain
  8. Table 8. Experience by state and domain
  9. Table 9. Gap by state and domain
§fw§

Foreword

Governments across the Arab region have expanded public services, infrastructure and formal entitlements over two decades. What residents report about those services has been measured far less often, and almost never in a way that separates two questions: can people reach what is provided, and how do they evaluate it when they do? This report answers both, for eleven domains of everyday life in ten states, and reads the difference between the answers as evidence about public administration.

The report is written for public officials, regulators, regional organisations and researchers. It does not rank states. It shows, for each state and each domain, whether access runs ahead of experience or the reverse, identifies five recurrent configurations of administrative deficit, and sets out what each implies for reform.

Dr Anis Ben Brik

Acknowledgements

This report was written by Dr Anis Ben Brik. It rests on the A-SCOPE MENA survey, Wave 1 (2026), 1,861 respondents in ten states. The instrument adapts the social inclusion measure developed by Huxley and colleagues (2012). Responsibility for any error rests with the author.

§sm§

Executive summary

Public provision reaches residents in most states and domains; experience lags behind. Across ten Arab states, reported access averages 57.1 and reported experience 51.3 on a 0–100 scale. Access exceeds experience in 74 of the 110 state–domain observations, and 26 gaps reach 20 points or more.

Reach is not delivery.

Higher reported access does not translate into higher reported experience: excluding Tunisia, the correlation between the two across states is 0.00.

The problem differs by domain.

In health and care access exceeds experience by 24.2 points on average and in nine states, which points to the quality and responsiveness of care that residents already reach. In digital access and use, experience exceeds access in every state, which points to reach.

National averages conceal the most consequential variation.

Tunisia records the highest access and experience in the region and the second-widest divergence across domains; Egypt shows no domain gap of 20 points or more.

Five gap types organise the evidence.

The Access–Delivery Gap and the Organisational–Coordination Gap are the most frequent (five states each); seven of the nineteen assignments hold under at least 90 per cent of alternative thresholds.

Alignment is not performance.

Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Kuwait show closely aligned access and experience at very different levels.

Way forward. Chapter 8 sets out reform directions by gap type under four headings: delivery quality where access runs ahead; reach where experience runs ahead; the administrative interface where large gaps concentrate in domains of direct contact; and coordination and capacity where divergence is wide. Two cross-cutting recommendations follow: domain-specific rather than aggregate targets, and the routine measurement of access and experience as a management instrument.

§gl§

The report at a glance

10 · 1,861states and respondents, Wave 1 (2026)
74 of 110state–domain observations in which access exceeds experience
+5.7regional mean gap, access minus experience
0.00correlation of access and experience across nine states, Tunisia excluded
+24.2mean gap in health and care, the widest domain
−10.6mean gap in digital access and use, negative in all ten states
19.2widest divergence across domains: Yemen
7 of 19gap-type assignments holding under 90 per cent of thresholds

States are identified by flag and name. Access is what residents report being able to reach; experience is how they evaluate what they reach; the gap is access minus experience, in points on a 0–100 scale. A positive gap means access exceeds experience. Large gaps are gaps of 20 points or more. Public-service domains are the ten domains other than family and social relationships. Samples are non-probability samples, so differences of a few points carry no weight.

§ch1§1

The state of play: access, experience and the gap

This chapter gives the regional overview: the levels of reported access and experience, the direction and size of the gap across the 110 observations, and the weak association between the two dimensions.

The Observatory assesses public services from the standpoint of the residents who use them. It measures two dimensions in each of eleven domains: access, the extent to which services, resources and opportunities can be reached, and experience, the degree of satisfaction with what is reached. The difference between the two, the access–experience gap, is the analytical core of the report.

The gap carries diagnostic information that neither dimension conveys alone. Where access exceeds experience, provision reaches residents without meeting their needs, and the questions that follow concern the quality, reliability and responsiveness of delivery. Where experience exceeds access, residents value what they reach but report reaching little, and the questions concern availability, eligibility, procedures and information.

Across the ten states, reported access averages 57.1 and reported experience 51.3, a mean gap of 5.7 points in favour of access. Access exceeds experience in 74 of the 110 state–domain observations. Of the 26 gaps of 20 points or more, 20 favour access and 6 favour experience.

The two dimensions are only weakly associated. The correlation between mean access and mean experience across the ten states is 0.45, and it depends on Tunisia, which records the highest values on both measures (64.9 and 67.6); among the other nine states the correlation is 0.00. The implication is substantive: states that report greater reach do not, as a rule, report more satisfactory services, so the expansion of access cannot be assumed to improve experience.

The first question is whether public provision, as residents experience it, is reaching them at all, and whether reach and evaluation move in step. The overview answers both: reach is broadly achieved, evaluation lags, and the two are only weakly related. The pattern that matters is the direction of the gap, which is positive in two observations out of three.

Figure 1The state of play: access, experience and the gap
Wave 1 (2026) · 10 states · 11 domains · 1,861 respondents

Why the gap, and not satisfaction alone. Satisfaction alone cannot separate a service that is hard to reach from one that is reached but poor. Read with access, the same experience score points to different problems: with high access, to delivery; with low access, to reach.
§ch2§2

Data and measurement

This chapter describes the survey, the construction of the access and experience scores, and the three features of the data that condition interpretation.

The first wave (2026) covers 1,861 respondents in ten states: Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Morocco, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia and Yemen. Access is measured with 120 items and experience with 68 items across eleven domains, each rescaled from 0 to 100; the gap is access minus experience, in points.

Three features of the data condition interpretation. (i) The samples are non-probability samples, so scores describe respondents rather than national populations. (ii) Access is measured mainly with yes/no items and experience with rating scales, so part of any gap reflects instrument design; the sign of a gap, and comparisons of the same domain across states, are the most defensible readings. (iii) The data are cross-sectional and do not observe administrative processes directly: administrative mechanisms enter the analysis as interpretations of the gaps, not as measured quantities.

§ch3§3

Findings by domain

This chapter groups the eleven domains by the direction and consistency of the gap and interprets each group.

Three groups of domains emerge. The first comprises domains in which access exceeds experience almost everywhere: housing and safety and policing (all ten states), and health and care, family and social relationships, and work, income and finance (nine states). Health and care records the largest mean gap (+24.2), reaching +46.1 in Yemen and more than +34 in Saudi Arabia and Qatar. The pattern is consistent with health systems that residents can reach but do not experience as adequate, which directs attention to the quality, affordability and responsiveness of care rather than to its availability alone.

The second group consists of digital access and use, the only domain in which experience exceeds access in every state (mean −10.6; −35.5 in Tunisia). Residents who reach digital services evaluate them favourably, but report limited reach, which points to constraints of connectivity, skills, channels and design rather than of quality.

The third group comprises domains that divide the states. In leisure and community participation, access and experience are inversely related across states (r = −0.82), with gaps ranging from −46.8 in Tunisia to +20.4 in Iraq. Service provision and assistance separates four states in which access exceeds experience (Yemen +30.0, Qatar +19.8, Saudi Arabia +14.8, Iraq +14.0) from six in which experience exceeds access, most markedly Morocco (−26.8), Lebanon (−19.4) and Egypt (−19.3). Civic participation and voice ranges from −32.8 in Morocco to +20.9 in Kuwait. In these domains the gap reflects contrasting arrangements of provision rather than a common regional pattern.

The domain table gives the regional means that the spectrum visualises and adds the count of states in which access exceeds experience. The two columns should be read as a pair: a large mean gap with a count near ten marks a regional pattern; a modest mean with a count near five marks a domain in which the states diverge and the mean itself is uninformative.

Table 1Regional access, experience and gap by domain
DomainAccessExperienceGapStates with access ahead
Health and care72.448.2+24.29
Family and social relationships75.155.6+19.49
Housing66.953.5+13.510
Safety and policing66.655.8+10.810
Work, income and finance59.250.4+8.89
Civic participation and voice49.146.1+3.07
Education and training51.250.1+1.17
Environmental conditions50.750.4+0.35
Service provision and assistance45.546.4−0.84
Leisure and community participation44.551.1−6.74
Digital access and use46.757.3−10.60

Regional means can conceal opposite movements within a domain. The spectrum places every state on every domain, so that the question becomes not how large the average gap is, but whether states agree on its direction. Where all ten points sit on one side of the axis, the pattern is regional; where they straddle it, the domain divides the region and a single reform prescription would misfire.

Figure 2The access–experience gap by domain

The access–experience gap by domain

Each track shows the gap in one domain for the ten states, from experience exceeding access (left) to access exceeding experience (right). Marker size is proportional to the size of the gap; the diamond marks the regional mean and shaded zones mark gaps of 20 points or more. Hovering over a state traces its position across all eleven domains.

Source: A-SCOPE MENA, Arab Access and Experience Dataset 2026 · non-probability samples; scores describe respondents.

§ch4§4

Findings by state

This chapter distinguishes three configurations of states and shows why aggregate indicators would misdescribe several of them.

Three configurations can be distinguished. (i) In Yemen (+16.8), Iraq (+12.5), Saudi Arabia (+10.5), Qatar (+10.1), Kuwait (+8.3) and Jordan (+6.6), access runs ahead of experience across most domains. Yemen combines the largest net gap with the widest divergence across domains (mean absolute gap 19.2), while Jordan records the smallest divergence in the region (9.4).

(ii) In Tunisia (−2.7), Morocco (−4.8) and Lebanon (+3.0), small net gaps conceal large gaps of opposite sign. Tunisia combines the highest levels of access and experience with the second-widest divergence (19.0): access exceeds experience by more than 23 points in housing, work, income and finance, and safety and policing, while experience exceeds access by 46.8 points in leisure and 35.5 points in digital access. For these states an aggregate indicator would be misleading; the analysis must proceed domain by domain.

(iii) Egypt (−2.9) shows no domain gap of 20 points or more; its negative gaps in services (−19.3) and civic participation (−19.2) indicate where reach, rather than quality, constrains residents.

The state table records the three measures separately, the divergence across domains, the number of large gaps and the gap types assigned. It is not a ranking: two states with the same net gap can differ widely in divergence, and the type column, not the net gap, carries the diagnostic content.

Table 2Access, experience and the gap by state
StateAccessExperienceGapMean absolute gapLarge gapsGap types
Egypt51.854.7−2.910.00Access–Experience Alignment
Iraq52.940.4+12.513.13Access–Delivery Gap and Access–Experience Alignment
Jordan57.751.1+6.69.41Access–Experience Alignment
Kuwait60.752.4+8.312.03Access–Delivery Gap and Access–Experience Alignment
Lebanon59.256.2+3.012.53Access–Delivery Gap, Administrative-Interface Gap and Organisational–Coordination Gap
Morocco52.056.8−4.814.84Access–Reach Gap, Administrative-Interface Gap and Organisational–Coordination Gap
Qatar58.448.3+10.114.02Organisational–Coordination Gap
Saudi Arabia54.243.7+10.512.82–
Tunisia64.967.6−2.719.05Access–Delivery Gap, Access–Reach Gap and Organisational–Coordination Gap
Yemen59.042.2+16.819.23Access–Delivery Gap, Administrative-Interface Gap and Organisational–Coordination Gap

A state is not described by its net gap. The profiles show, for each state, the shape formed by its eleven domain gaps. Compact profiles indicate a consistent relation between reach and evaluation; profiles with large petals in both directions indicate offsetting gaps whose sum is close to zero and whose administrative meanings differ.

Figure 3Gap profiles by state

Gap profiles by state

Each profile represents one state. In the fingerprint, petals extending outward from the reference ring mark domains in which access exceeds experience, and petals extending inward mark the reverse; the dashed rings mark gaps of 20 points and the centre gives the overall gap. The skyline presents the same values as towers above and reflections below a horizon.

Source: A-SCOPE MENA, Arab Access and Experience Dataset 2026 · non-probability samples; scores describe respondents.

Reading Tunisia. Tunisia records the highest access (64.9) and experience (67.6) in the region and a net gap of −2.7, which an aggregate indicator would read as balance. Domain by domain, access exceeds experience by more than 23 points in housing, work and finance, and safety, while experience exceeds access by 46.8 points in leisure and 35.5 in digital services.
§ch5§5

The administrative interface

This chapter examines the five domains of direct contact between residents and public institutions, where procedures, information and complaint handling shape experience.

The five domains in which residents deal directly with public institutions are service provision and assistance, health and care, education and training, safety and policing, and civic participation and voice. Two of them, health and safety, show access above experience almost everywhere; the other three divide the region, and that division is where the administrative interface becomes visible.

Service provision and assistance separates two groups. In Yemen (+30.0), Qatar (+19.8), Saudi Arabia (+14.8) and Iraq (+14.0) residents report reaching assistance they do not evaluate as adequate. In Morocco (−26.8), Lebanon (−19.4) and Egypt (−19.3) the relation is reversed: those who obtain assistance evaluate it comparatively well, but report obtaining little. The same service function therefore produces opposite diagnoses: procedures and treatment in the first group, eligibility, information and administrative burden in the second.

Civic participation and voice shows the widest spread of any interface domain, from −32.8 in Morocco to +20.9 in Kuwait. Where the gap is strongly negative, residents who participate report being heard while most report no channel to use; where it is positive, formal channels exist but the experience of using them falls short.

Education and training is the most closely aligned interface domain (regional mean +1.1), with large negative gaps in Tunisia (−13.4) and Morocco (−14.4) and a large positive gap in Kuwait (+15.8).

In Lebanon, Morocco and Yemen at least half of all large gaps fall in these five domains. For those states the interface is not one problem among others: it is where the administrative relationship with residents is most strained, and where procedures, communication, frontline discretion and redress mechanisms warrant examination first.

The five interface domains are where residents meet officials, forms and procedures directly. The table isolates their gaps to show where the administrative relationship is under strain in each state, and how many of a state's large gaps fall in these domains.

Table 3The gap in the five interface domains
StateServicesHealthEducationSafetyCivicLarge gaps
Morocco−26.8+20.4−14.4+1.1−32.83
Lebanon−19.4+23.5+3.6+21.7+8.52
Yemen+30.0+46.1+7.2+10.8+16.52
Tunisia−15.0−1.6−13.4+23.6+13.71
Kuwait−3.6+15.1+15.8+6.7+20.91
Jordan−2.9+24.0+1.2+16.5−0.91
Qatar+19.8+34.3+9.4+13.1+0.51
Saudi Arabia+14.8+34.5+0.4+6.0+11.01
Iraq+14.0+27.9+7.2+0.6+11.61
Egypt−19.3+17.7−6.0+8.4−19.20
§ch6§6

A typology of administrative deficits

This chapter turns from description to diagnosis. Five gap types, each defined by an explicit rule and associated with an administrative deficit, organise the configurations, and their stability is tested.

Five gap types, each defined by an explicit rule on the gaps in the ten public-service domains, organise these configurations and link each to an administrative deficit. At the selected thresholds, the Access–Delivery Gap (implementation and service-delivery deficit) and the Organisational–Coordination Gap (administrative capacity and coordination deficit) are the most frequent, each observed in five states. The Administrative-Interface Gap is observed in Lebanon, Morocco and Yemen; the Access–Reach Gap (service-design and access deficit) in Morocco and Tunisia; and Access–Experience Alignment in Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Kuwait. Saudi Arabia shows no gap type.

The classification is tested against alternative thresholds. Seven of the nineteen current assignments hold under at least 90 per cent of the threshold specifications examined; the most threshold-dependent are the Access–Delivery Gap assignments of Kuwait (42 per cent) and Lebanon (48 per cent), which should be read with corresponding caution.

The typology table pairs each empirical rule with the administrative deficit it is read as indicating. The pairing is interpretive: the rule is measured, the deficit is inferred. The states listed are those meeting the rule at the selected thresholds.

Table 4Gap-type membership and stability
Gap typeAdministrative deficitStates
Access–Delivery GapImplementation & Service-Delivery DeficitIraq, Kuwait, Lebanon, Tunisia and Yemen
Access–Reach GapService-Design & Access DeficitMorocco and Tunisia
Administrative-Interface GapAdministrative-Interface DeficitLebanon, Morocco and Yemen
Organisational–Coordination GapAdministrative Capacity & Coordination DeficitLebanon, Morocco, Qatar, Tunisia and Yemen
Access–Experience AlignmentNo pronounced administrative deficitEgypt, Iraq, Jordan and Kuwait

The typology turns configurations into a small number of diagnostic categories. Membership is shown as a matrix so that overlaps are visible: a state may combine a delivery gap with wide divergence, or show none of the five configurations. The question this figure answers is which types co-occur, and which states fall outside the typology at the selected thresholds.

Figure 4Gap-type membership

Gap-type membership

Filled markers indicate the gap types identified for each state at the selected thresholds; connecting lines indicate combinations of types. Bars report the number of states in each type.

Source: A-SCOPE MENA, Arab Access and Experience Dataset 2026 · non-probability samples; scores describe respondents.

A classification that depends on an arbitrary threshold is not a finding. Each assignment was recomputed under alternative thresholds for the size of a large gap and the number of domains required. Assignments that hold under most specifications can be relied upon; assignments that appear only in a narrow band should be treated as provisional.

Figure 5Stability of classification

Stability of classification

Bubble size is proportional to the share of threshold combinations under which each state is assigned to each gap type (large gap of 15 to 25 points in one to three domains; alignment below 3 to 7 points in two to four domains). An outline marks assignment at the selected thresholds.

Source: A-SCOPE MENA, Arab Access and Experience Dataset 2026 · non-probability samples; scores describe respondents.

§ch7§7

Discussion

This chapter states three propositions that the evidence supports and the limits of the diagnostic reading.

The findings support three interpretive propositions. First, the principal problem revealed by the survey is not the absence of provision but its conversion into services that residents value: in most states and most domains, residents report reaching more than they evaluate favourably. Second, the problem differs by domain: in health and care it concerns the quality of what is reached, whereas in digital services it concerns reach itself. Third, national averages conceal the most consequential variation, which lies across domains within the same state.

These propositions are consistent with an administrative reading of the gap, in which implementation, frontline delivery, procedures and coordination determine how far formal provision becomes effective and valued. The survey does not observe these processes directly, and the propositions are therefore offered as interpretations to be examined with administrative and qualitative evidence.

What the evidence can and cannot support. The findings support a reading of the region in which public provision has, in most places, outrun its conversion into services that residents value. The evidence is descriptive: what it establishes is the direction and size of the difference between reported access and reported experience, not the mechanism that produces it. Three interpretations are consistent with the evidence and should be held side by side.

The first is administrative: gaps arise where implementation, frontline practice, procedures or coordination fall short, which is the reading the typology adopts. The second is instrumental: access items are mainly binary and experience items are rating scales, so part of every positive gap may be an artefact of format; this cannot be excluded until the two are equated. The third concerns expectations: experience is an evaluation relative to what residents expect, and expectations differ across states and social groups, so identical services may yield different experience scores. None of these interpretations excludes the others, and their relative weight is an empirical question for later waves.

What should not be inferred is a ranking of states, a causal attribution to any particular ministry or reform, or a national estimate. Samples are non-probability samples; differences of a few points are within the noise of the design. What can be inferred with more confidence is the sign of a gap within a state and domain, the contrast between domains within a state, and the contrast between states within a domain, all of which are stable under the alternative thresholds tested.

The most consequential discrepancies are the offsetting gaps in Tunisia, Morocco and Lebanon, where aggregate indicators would report balance while residents face opposite problems in different domains, and the uniformity of the digital domain, where every state shows reach as the constraint. Both point to a management practice of monitoring access and experience jointly and domain by domain. For research, the priority questions are whether the gaps persist under harmonised item formats, whether the instrument is invariant across states, and whether the states assigned to each gap type show the corresponding administrative characteristics in independent data.

§ch8§8

The way forward

This chapter sets out reform directions by gap type and recommendations by actor.

Delivery quality where access runs ahead. In health and care, housing, safety and policing, and work, income and finance, performance management should extend beyond coverage to the quality and responsiveness of delivery: waiting times, the reliability of services, the conduct of frontline staff and the handling of user problems.

Reach where experience runs ahead. In digital access and use, and in services, leisure and civic participation in the states where experience exceeds access, reform should concentrate on service design, eligibility and targeting, outreach and information, and the administrative burden that conditions entry.

The administrative interface. Where large gaps concentrate in domains of direct contact with public institutions, as in Lebanon, Morocco and Yemen, procedures, communication with users, the consistency of frontline discretion and complaint and redress mechanisms warrant review.

Coordination and capacity. Where divergence is wide across many domains, as in Tunisia, Yemen, Morocco, Lebanon and Qatar, uneven implementation across sectors points to the need for coordination between agencies and for stronger organisational capacity.

Domain-specific rather than aggregate targets. Because aggregates conceal offsetting gaps, performance frameworks should set and monitor targets domain by domain, for access and experience jointly.

Citizen assessment as a management instrument. The routine measurement of access and experience in the same domains, ideally with probability samples and repeated waves, would allow governments to monitor the gap over time and to assess the effect of reforms on it.

Reform directions are organised by gap type rather than by state, because states sharing a type share a problem structure. Each row moves from evidence to the direction of reform and to the indicator whose movement would show whether the reform is working.

Table 5Reform directions by gap type
Gap typeStatesEvidenceDirection of reformIndicator to track
Access–Delivery GapIraq, Kuwait, Lebanon, Tunisia and YemenAccess exceeds experience by 20 points or more in at least two public-service domainsQuality, reliability and responsiveness of delivery in the domains concernedExperience score in those domains
Access–Reach GapMorocco and TunisiaExperience exceeds access by 20 points or more in at least two domainsService design, eligibility, outreach and administrative burdenAccess score in those domains
Administrative-Interface GapLebanon, Morocco and YemenLarge gaps concentrated in services, health, education, safety and civic voiceProcedures, communication, frontline discretion, complaint and redress mechanismsGap in interface domains
Organisational–Coordination GapLebanon, Morocco, Qatar, Tunisia and YemenMean absolute gap above the regional medianCoordination across agencies, organisational capacity, institutionalisation of deliveryMean absolute gap
Access–Experience AlignmentEgypt, Iraq, Jordan and KuwaitGap under 5 points in at least three public-service domainsRaise the level of both dimensions where both are low; alignment is not performanceAccess and experience levels

Practitioner recommendations

Table 6Practitioner recommendations
PriorityActionResponsible actorsIntended outcome
Delivery quality in the health, housing, safety and work domains, where access exceeds experience in nine or ten statesPublish and monitor waiting times, service reliability and complaint resolution rates at facility level; introduce user feedback at the point of serviceLine ministries; regulators; facility managersExperience scores rise towards access scores in these domains
Reach in digital services, where experience exceeds access in all ten statesAudit eligibility rules, documentation requirements and channel availability for the main digital services; simplify and publish themDigital government units; sector ministriesAccess scores rise without a fall in experience
The administrative interface in Lebanon, Morocco and Yemen, where large gaps concentrate in contact domainsMap procedures and decision criteria for the most used services; establish and measure complaint and redress channelsCentres of government; frontline agenciesGaps in interface domains narrow
Coordination where divergence is wide (Tunisia, Yemen, Morocco, Lebanon, Qatar)Assign cross-sector responsibility for the domains with the largest gaps; report jointly on access and experienceCentres of government; planning ministriesMean absolute gap declines
MeasurementRepeat the survey with probability samples, harmonised item formats and the same domains; publish data and codebookNational statistical offices; the ObservatoryGaps can be tracked over time and compared across states with known error

Recommendations by actor

Centres of government. Set and monitor targets for access and experience domain by domain; aggregate targets conceal offsetting gaps.

Line ministries and agencies. Where access runs ahead, manage delivery quality: waiting times, reliability, frontline conduct and the handling of user problems. Where experience runs ahead, manage reach: eligibility, information, channels and burden.

Frontline organisations. Publish procedures, decision criteria and complaint channels; measure response times.

National statistical offices. Institutionalise the joint measurement of access and experience, on probability samples, in the same domains, at regular intervals.

Regional organisations. Adopt a common instrument so that access, experience and the gap can be compared across states.

§ch9§9

Country notes

A short note for each of the ten states: the evidence and the priority that follows from it. Each note links to a full country brief.

Egypt

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 5 of the 11 domains. No domain gap reaches 20 points. The gap is under 5 points in 3 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Experience Alignment.

Priority. Repeated measurement of access and experience in the same domains would allow the effect of reforms on the gap to be assessed over time.

Access 51.8 · Experience 54.7 · Gap −2.9 · Mean absolute gap 10.0 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 0 · Country brief

Iraq

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 10 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in family and social relationships (+34.3); health and care (+27.9); and leisure and community participation (+20.4) (access above experience). The gap is under 5 points in 3 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Delivery Gap, Access–Experience Alignment.

Priority. In health and care; and leisure and community participation, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach.

Access 52.9 · Experience 40.4 · Gap +12.5 · Mean absolute gap 13.1 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 3 · Country brief

Jordan

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 7 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in health and care (+24.0) (access above experience). The gap is under 5 points in 4 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Experience Alignment.

Priority. In health and care, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach.

Access 57.7 · Experience 51.1 · Gap +6.6 · Mean absolute gap 9.4 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 1 · Country brief

Kuwait

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 7 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in family and social relationships (+25.6); housing (+21.4); and civic participation and voice (+20.9) (access above experience). The gap is under 5 points in 3 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Delivery Gap, Access–Experience Alignment.

Priority. In housing; and civic participation and voice, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach.

Access 60.7 · Experience 52.4 · Gap +8.3 · Mean absolute gap 12.0 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 3 · Country brief

Lebanon

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 8 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in health and care (+23.5); and safety and policing (+21.7) (access above experience) and in leisure and community participation (−24.7) (experience above access). The gap is under 5 points in 2 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Delivery Gap, Administrative-Interface Gap, Organisational–Coordination Gap.

Priority. In health and care; and safety and policing, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach. In leisure and community participation, where experience exceeds access by 20 points or more, the priority lies in reach: the design of services, eligibility rules and targeting, outreach and information, and the administrative burden and access channels that condition entry.

Access 59.2 · Experience 56.2 · Gap +3.0 · Mean absolute gap 12.5 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 3 · Country brief

Morocco

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 6 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in health and care (+20.4) (access above experience) and in civic participation and voice (−32.8); service provision and assistance (−26.8); and leisure and community participation (−22.2) (experience above access). The gap is under 5 points in 2 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Reach Gap, Administrative-Interface Gap, Organisational–Coordination Gap.

Priority. In health and care, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach. In civic participation and voice; service provision and assistance; and leisure and community participation, where experience exceeds access by 20 points or more, the priority lies in reach: the design of services, eligibility rules and targeting, outreach and information, and the administrative burden and access channels that condition entry.

Access 52.0 · Experience 56.8 · Gap −4.8 · Mean absolute gap 14.8 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 4 · Country brief

Qatar

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 9 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in health and care (+34.3); and family and social relationships (+28.5) (access above experience). The gap is under 5 points in 2 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Organisational–Coordination Gap.

Priority. In health and care, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach.

Access 58.4 · Experience 48.3 · Gap +10.1 · Mean absolute gap 14.0 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 2 · Country brief

Saudi Arabia

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 9 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in health and care (+34.5); and family and social relationships (+31.8) (access above experience). The gap is under 5 points in 2 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: No gap type at these thresholds.

Priority. In health and care, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach.

Access 54.2 · Experience 43.7 · Gap +10.5 · Mean absolute gap 12.8 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 2 · Country brief

Tunisia

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 4 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in housing (+26.2); work, income and finance (+26.0); and safety and policing (+23.6) (access above experience) and in leisure and community participation (−46.8); and digital access and use (−35.5) (experience above access). The gap is under 5 points in 2 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Delivery Gap, Access–Reach Gap, Organisational–Coordination Gap.

Priority. In housing; safety and policing; and work, income and finance, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach. In leisure and community participation; and digital access and use, where experience exceeds access by 20 points or more, the priority lies in reach: the design of services, eligibility rules and targeting, outreach and information, and the administrative burden and access channels that condition entry.

Access 64.9 · Experience 67.6 · Gap −2.7 · Mean absolute gap 19.0 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 5 · Country brief

Yemen

Evidence. Access exceeds experience in 9 of the 11 domains. Large gaps (20 points or more) occur in family and social relationships (+48.4); health and care (+46.1); and service provision and assistance (+30.0) (access above experience). The gap is under 5 points in 1 of the ten public-service domains. Gap types: Access–Delivery Gap, Administrative-Interface Gap, Organisational–Coordination Gap.

Priority. In health and care; and service provision and assistance, where access exceeds experience by 20 points or more, the priority lies in the quality of delivery: the consistency of frontline practice, the responsiveness of organisations to users, and the reliability and timeliness of services that residents already reach.

Access 59.0 · Experience 42.2 · Gap +16.8 · Mean absolute gap 19.2 · Large gaps (20 points or more) 3 · Country brief

§ch10§10

Conclusion

This report has treated what residents report about public services as evidence about public administration. Across ten Arab states and eleven domains, provision generally reaches residents; what they experience falls short of what they reach in most domains and most states, and the two dimensions are only weakly related. The gap between them varies by domain in direction and by state in structure, and five recurrent configurations organise that variation.

The practical lesson is that access and experience must be measured and managed as a pair. Coverage targets that ignore experience will report success where residents report disappointment; satisfaction surveys that ignore access will miss the residents who never reach the service. The Observatory will repeat the measurement, and this report sets the baseline against which change can be judged.

§anA§

Annex A. Methodology

The first wave (2026) covers 1,861 respondents in ten states: Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Morocco, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia and Yemen. Access is measured with 120 items and experience with 68 items across eleven domains, each rescaled from 0 to 100; the gap is access minus experience, in points.

Three features of the data condition interpretation. (i) The samples are non-probability samples, so scores describe respondents rather than national populations. (ii) Access is measured mainly with yes/no items and experience with rating scales, so part of any gap reflects instrument design; the sign of a gap, and comparisons of the same domain across states, are the most defensible readings. (iii) The data are cross-sectional and do not observe administrative processes directly: administrative mechanisms enter the analysis as interpretations of the gaps, not as measured quantities.

§anB§

Annex B. Data tables

The annex tables reproduce the published scores so that every figure in this report can be verified and any reader can recompute the gaps.

Table 7Access by state and domain
StateHealthSocialHousingSafetyFinanceCivicEducationEnvironmentServicesLeisureDigital
Egypt68.671.457.367.347.936.244.651.135.738.152.3
Iraq64.871.259.943.852.750.951.548.350.757.730.8
Jordan73.870.365.873.359.048.949.350.144.543.556.0
Kuwait63.976.366.459.362.567.857.851.756.146.759.0
Lebanon71.674.375.278.853.944.463.561.828.836.762.5
Morocco77.873.358.971.468.126.533.158.425.834.644.1
Qatar73.375.662.267.455.149.267.246.963.947.434.5
Saudi Arabia74.371.567.750.055.546.052.635.656.547.838.8
Tunisia76.881.392.6100.089.964.225.363.626.534.558.8
Yemen78.885.563.155.147.457.267.239.766.857.530.0
Table 8Experience by state and domain
StateHealthSocialHousingSafetyFinanceCivicEducationEnvironmentServicesLeisureDigital
Egypt50.963.254.458.949.155.450.648.755.053.661.9
Iraq36.936.950.643.241.739.344.343.736.737.333.8
Jordan49.855.853.456.846.649.848.143.547.447.863.6
Kuwait48.850.745.052.656.746.942.063.959.747.762.7
Lebanon48.169.764.857.151.735.959.951.248.261.470.5
Morocco57.469.258.070.352.859.347.545.052.656.855.6
Qatar39.047.146.454.349.048.757.852.744.142.750.1
Saudi Arabia39.839.751.244.048.935.052.244.641.741.542.2
Tunisia78.487.066.476.463.950.538.765.241.581.394.3
Yemen32.737.144.344.343.640.760.045.536.841.337.9
Table 9Gap by state and domain
StateHealthSocialHousingSafetyFinanceCivicEducationEnvironmentServicesLeisureDigital
Egypt+17.7+8.2+2.9+8.4−1.2−19.2−6.0+2.4−19.3−15.5−9.6
Iraq+27.9+34.3+9.3+0.6+11.0+11.6+7.2+4.6+14.0+20.4−3.0
Jordan+24.0+14.5+12.4+16.5+12.4−0.9+1.2+6.6−2.9−4.3−7.6
Kuwait+15.1+25.6+21.4+6.7+5.8+20.9+15.8−12.2−3.6−1.0−3.7
Lebanon+23.5+4.6+10.4+21.7+2.2+8.5+3.6+10.6−19.4−24.7−8.0
Morocco+20.4+4.1+0.9+1.1+15.3−32.8−14.4+13.4−26.8−22.2−11.5
Qatar+34.3+28.5+15.8+13.1+6.1+0.5+9.4−5.8+19.8+4.7−15.6
Saudi Arabia+34.5+31.8+16.5+6.0+6.6+11.0+0.4−9.0+14.8+6.3−3.4
Tunisia−1.6−5.7+26.2+23.6+26.0+13.7−13.4−1.6−15.0−46.8−35.5
Yemen+46.1+48.4+18.8+10.8+3.8+16.5+7.2−5.8+30.0+16.2−7.9
§refs§

References

  1. Huxley, P., Evans, S., Madge, S., Webber, M., Burchardt, T., McDaid, D., & Knapp, M. (2012). Development of a social inclusion index to capture subjective and objective life domains (Phase II). Health Technology Assessment, 16(1), 1–241.
  2. Lipsky, M. (1980). Street-level bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the individual in public services. Russell Sage Foundation.
  3. Herd, P., & Moynihan, D. P. (2018). Administrative burden: Policymaking by other means. Russell Sage Foundation.
  4. Moynihan, D., Herd, P., & Harvey, H. (2015). Administrative burden: Learning, psychological, and compliance costs in citizen-state interactions. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 25(1), 43–69.
  5. Pressman, J. L., & Wildavsky, A. (1973). Implementation. University of California Press.
  6. Sen, A. (1999). Development as freedom. Oxford University Press.
  7. Van Ryzin, G. G. (2004). Expectations, performance, and citizen satisfaction with urban services. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 23(3), 433–448.
  8. Stipak, B. (1979). Citizen satisfaction with urban services: Potential misuse as a performance indicator. Public Administration Review, 39(1), 46–52.
مرصد الإدارةin the Arab RegionCitizens Voice

Notes and sources

Country names and flags follow the usage of the League of Arab States. Samples are non-probability samples; scores describe respondents rather than national populations, and comparisons are indicative. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the institutions with which he is affiliated.

Please cite this publication as: Ben Brik, A. (2026). Public Services, Resources and Opportunities: Access and Experience. What citizens report across ten Arab states, Wave 1 (2026). Administration Observatory in the Arab Region (Marsad Edara), https://marsad-edara.org/report/annual-2026/.